We examined the effect of positive autoregulation on the steady-state behavior of the PhoQ/PhoP two-component signaling system in Escherichia coli. We found that autoregulation has no effect on the steady-state output for a large range of input stimulus, which was modulated by varying the concentration of magnesium in the growth medium. We provide an explanation for this finding with a simple model of the PhoQ/PhoP circuit. The model predicts that even when autoregulation is manifest across a range of stimulus levels, the effects of positive feedback on the steady-state output emerge only in the limit that the system is strongly stimulated. Consistent with this prediction, amplification associated with autoregulation was observed in growth-limiting levels of magnesium, a condition that strongly activates PhoQ/PhoP. In a further test of the model, we found that strains harboring a phosphatase-defective PhoQ showed strong positive feedback and considerable cell-to-cell variability under growth conditions where the wild-type circuit did not show this behavior. Our results demonstrate a simple and general mechanism for regulating the positive feedback associated with autoregulation within a bacterial signaling circuit to boost response range and maintain a relatively uniform and graded output.